So here is the interview below, with modern day 15-year-old Rebecca's answers followed by what 15-year-old Catie would have said. (By the way, 15-year-old Catie was pretty much the furthest thing from a fashion expert that you could possibly imagine. The photos below should be proof enough.)
: Doc Martens are huge right now. You see them in every color—yellow, pink, black—some have a British flag on them. Jackets with big shoulder pads are also really big, and headbands with huge bows. My mom hates mine. It’s got the most obnoxiously big bow you’ve ever seen in your life. I’d also put furry vests, suede fringed jackets and navy and white striped t-shirts on the list. Oh yeah, and off the shoulder sweatshirts—it’s an 80s aerobic instructor look.
: Oh brother. If anything remotely resembling the 80s comes your way, start running in the other direction. True, Doc Martens are amazing (although my parents won't buy me any because they think they're ugly) and now they are even more covetable because they have branched out from just boots to oxfords and mary janes, too. And since we're talking shoes, get some Jack Purcells in either blue, white, or black. Back off from Converse, it's kind of over-played, and Airwalk too - those are for skaters.
15-year-old Rebecca: Yes, pill box hats with a piece of tulle. It looks really over the top. People wear them to school with Doc Martens and schoolboy blazers, or with MC Hammer pants that pouf out.
15-year-old Catie: Keep a scrunchie on your wrist. Wear it like a bracelet and don't ask questions. Also, have you seen
Clueless? Those thigh highs are amazing but pretty much everyone is too afraid to wear them. Plus I think they might be against our dress code.
W: Where do you get the pillbox hats? Who has pillbox hats anymore?15-year-old Rebecca: Most get them from their mothers or grandmothers, but you can also get them at a few stores in Soho such as the Hat Shop.
15-year-old Catie: Wait, pillbox hats? Isn't that what Jackie Kennedy wore? We're learning about all those people in American History. But hey, since we're on the topic of gossip, may I suggest showing up to class wearing things that give people clues to how cool your life is outside of school. Did you go skiing this past weekend? Keep your zipper tags attached to your jacket, and don't take your jacket off for three days. If you went to a concert, wear the t-shirt to school the next day and fall asleep at your desk during fourth period. After spring break, come back with a tan or even a burn to show everyone that you went to Mexico or Hawaii or some place tropical. Wear a puka shell necklace, too. The white shells stand out against your tan and make you look even tanner! That said, puka shells may or may not be code for 'Dude, I totally smoke weed.' Woven hemp necklaces, on the other hand, send a much stronger message that yes, you totally smoke weed. And if there's a big glass bead with a giant mushroom frozen inside dangling from the middle of your hemp necklace, you're totally a poseur and don't smoke weed at all.
W: What do your friends carry their stuff to school in?15-year-old Rebecca: Either Longchamp Tote bags or backpacks. Most have American Apparel backpacks—either the black glittery one or the neon orange one.
15-year-old Catie: Solid-colored Jansport backpacks are the gold standard, but something big and complicated from The North Face that would never see the inside of a campground in its lifetime is the most desirable. The more random clips and buckles that hang off of it, the better. Adorn your backpack with a few tastefully placed patches and ironic one-inch buttons, or your favorite hair ribbon. But most of all, always wear your backpack on both shoulders.
W: How big a fashion influence is Gossip Girl?15-year-old Rebecca: None of these ideas come from
Gossip Girl, considering that most girls who live and go to high school on the Upper East Side do not watch
Gossip Girl because they think it's pretentious and exaggerated. The pillbox hat idea predates
Gossip Girl. They have been popular since before the show came out.
15-year-old Catie: Okay, can we lay off the pillbox hats for a second? Here, have an Altoid - I keep a tin of them in my Jansport backpack. And since we're on the subject of influential TV shows, I should probably mention that pretty much anything Monica or Rachel wear on
Friends is worth noting. Phoebe, not so much. Also if you can get your hair to look like Rachel's you are on another level altogether. This is something few can achieve, so keep your hair on the longer side with either no bangs or bangs curled straight across to perfection. I myself will strive for the shoulder-length
Angela Chase-style bob for years to come.
W: Is preppy style still going strong?15-year-old Rebecca: Well Topsiders are big, but now they’re purple with plaid, or yellow or pink patent leather. You also see girls wearing button-down boys shirts, really baggy ones that are belted, with leggings and Keds. Usually red Keds, sometimes white. Plaid flannel shirts are also popular, but in really ridiculous patterns like checked turquoise and purple or pink and black.
15-year-old Catie: Most people at my school live and die in preppy style. You kind of either totally do it or you totally don't. Flip through the newest J. Crew catalogue or A&F Quarterly when you should be taking notes on the Kennedys during history class.
W: What isn’t considered cool anymore?15-year-old Rebecca: Uggs. You wear them only if it’s really freezing outside or if you’re going to Starbucks. But if you show up to school wearing jeans, a t-shirt and Uggs, that’s considered a big no-no.
15-year-old Catie: Stuff that makes you look like a kid. Leave that shit from the Disney Store at home. Sure, they make adult sizes but that doesn't mean you should wear it. And stay away from sweatshirts with puffy paint flowers or Garfield on them. If your sweatshirt says anything at all, it should be something along the lines of 'Nautica' or 'Eddie Bauer' or the name of some top-tier private university that you really hope you get accepted to.
W: What about jeans? How specific do you have to be?15-year-old Rebecca: Everybody used to wear normal blue jeans, but now, unless your jeans are very cool—either very bell bottomy jeans or super, super tight skinny jeans—they’re considered sweat pants. That’s what people call them. You just look way too comfortable and it looks sloppy.
15-year-old Catie: Something stonewashed, mid-rise, and slightly baggy from the Gap or Levi's is the way to go. Ask yourself if this is something Jerry Seinfeld would wear. If the answer is yes, it's a green light, my friend. Accessorize with either an extra-long brown leather woven belt or a cutesy ribbon one from Abercrombie.